Volcanoes’ Big Carbon Burps Small Deal Compared to Human CO2 Output

Emissions From Human Activities in 2010 was 135 Times More Than Those From Volcanoes

Human activities put out in just three to five days, the same amount of carbon dioxide that volcanoes produce globally each year.

US Geological Survey scientist Terrance Gerlach, makes this calculation in a new article, “Volcanic Versus Anthropogenic Carbon Dioxide,” in this week’s issue of Eos, the American Geophysical Union’s weekly newspaper.

Photo courtesy, DW Peterson/US National Park ServiceKilauea Volcano at Mauna Ulu, Hawai’i, when it erupted in 1972.

“The most frequent question that I have gotten (and still get), in my 30 some years as a volcanic gas geochemist from the general public and from geoscientists working in fields outside of volcanology, is: ‘Do volcanoes emit more CO2 than human activities?’ Research findings indicate unequivocally that the answer to this question is ‘No — anthropogenic CO2 emissions dwarf global volcanic CO2 emissions,” says Gerlach.

In fact, calculations show that carbon emissions caused by human activities in 2010 — an estimated 35 gigatons — was about 135 times the average emissions from volcanoes during the same period (about 0.26 gigatons), he notes.

This new information places human activity as a major contributor to greenhouse gases. Deniers of human influence on climate change often cite carbon emissions from natural sources like, plants, animals and volcanoes, claiming they release way more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere than we do via our gas-guzzling and forest-razing lifestyles.

It’s true that the sum total of CO2 released from natural sources, especially plant and animal life, is way higher than what we humans put out through our activities (studies peg it at 20 times more), but, Gerlach explains, most of that carbon gets recycled and balanced out by natural carbon sinks, largely via photosynthesis of carbon compounds by plants.

“The carbon that’s really critical is not the carbon that’s recycled, but the carbon that’s new to the earth’s surface environment that doesn’t get recycled,” Gerlach told the Journal today. “One of the biggest natural sources of such carbon dioxide is volcanoes, the other is fossil fuel burning.”

Gerlach looked at five published studies of present-day global volcanic CO2 emissions that give a range of results — from a minimum of about one tenth of a billion metric tons, to a maximum of about half a billion metric tons of CO2 per year — and went with an average of one-quarter of a billion metric tons of volcanic CO2 per year. He then compared it to the estimated anthropogenic CO2 emission rate for 2010 — about 35 billion metric tons per year (calculated by a team from the University of Exeter, UK, led by carbon cycle expert Pierre Friedlingstein).

Gerlach’s calculations suggest present-day annual anthropogenic CO2 emissions exceed the carbon output of even one or more volcanic super-eruptions per year! (Super-eruptions are extremely rare. The most recent examples being the Toba eruption 74,000 years ago in Indonesia and the Yellowstone caldera eruption in the United States 2 million years ago.)

“Indeed, volcanoes emit significantly less CO2 than land use changes (3.4 gigatons per year), light-duty vehicles (3.0 gigatons per year, mainly cars and pickup trucks), or cement production (1.4 gigatons per year),” Gerlach writes in the Eos report. “This pattern… reflects the 650% growth in anthropogenic emissions since 1900, about 550% of which has occurred since 1950,” he writes.

Bottomline — Volcanoes’ big carbon burps are small deal in comparison to our CO2 output.

You Make Our Work Possible

You Make Our Work Possible

We are standing at a pivotal moment in history, one in which education and advocacy around the climate emergency, public health, racial injustice, and economic inequity is imperative. At Earth Island Journal, we have doubled down on our commitment to uplifting stories that often go unheard, to centering the voices of frontline communities, and to always speak truth to power. We are nonprofit publication. We don’t have a paywall because our mission is to inform, educate and inspire action. Which is why we rely on readers like you for support. If you believe in the work we do, please consider making a tax-deductible year-end donation to our Green Journalism Fund.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

The Latest

Sailing the Seas on Reused Plastic

A traditional Swahili dhow known as the FlipFlopi shows that environmental innovation can coexist with tradition.

Tasha Goldberg

A Plea to Recognize the Legal Rights of the Maas River

I am advocating for a new legal status for the Maas in the hope that it becomes the first river in Europe with rights.

Jessica den Outer

Nearly 60 Million Americans Don’t Drink Their Tap Water, Research Suggests

Distrust and disuse of tap water is a public health problem.

Asher Rosinger

Uruguay’s Remarkable Shift to Renewables Offers a Blueprint for Energy Progress

However, the country’s ground-breaking energy initiatives now face a new challenge — a new governing party with more conservative views.

Andy McDonough

Biden in Risky Talks to Pay Brazil to Save Amazon

Activists fear billion-dollar climate deal will bolster Bolsonaro and reward illegal forest clearance, but US says action can’t wait.

Jonathan Watts The Guardian

Illinois Wind Farm Project Threatens Rare Frog Species

Researchers say that the 30,000-acre Glacier Sands Wind Project could jeopardize Illinois chorus frogs, which burrow and feed underground.

Niko McCarty