Environmental Movement Is Having a Real Impact in the US, Study Finds

States with strong green voices perform better on cutting emissions whereas those with climate sceptic views have seen emissions rise

By Damian Carrington

The environmental movement is making a real difference in the US, according to a new research that shows states with strong green voices have significantly lower emissions of the gases that drive global warming.

Photo of Fracking ProtestPhoto by CREDO.fracking Activists protest fracking outside Governor Cuomo’s office in New York. States like New York and Vermont, with stronger environmental voices, have cut their emissions despite rising populations and affluence.

The study is one of the first to quantify the real impact of green politics on the environment. It reveals that more environmentally friendly states, such as New York and Vermont, have cut their greenhouse gas emissions despite rising population and affluence. But other states like Texas and Wyoming, where skepticism about climate change is much stronger, have seen emissions rise.

The work, published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, compared greenhouse gas emissions of each state going back to 1990 with the level of environmentalism. The latter was measured using the environmental voting record of the state’s congressmen and congresswomen as rated by the League of Conservation Voters. Previous work has shown voting records are a good indicator of voters’ opinions.

Professor Thomas Dietz, at Michigan State University and who led the research, said that, since 1990, economic growth and rising population usually drove up carbon emissions, but that this could reversed with rises in green attitudes. “If we increase environmentalism at about the same scale as economic growth, we can offset the impact,” he said.

Dietz said the finding also indicated that solutions to environmental problems do not emerge automatically as an economy grows, but needed a broad and strong environmental movement to develop: “From households to businesses, governments and the environmental groups, environmental activism is absolutely essential — these things don’t just happen.”

The study did not examine the mechanisms by which green activism reduced emissions but Dietz said it was likely to be a combination of green policies, more active implementation of those policies and action taken by both households and businesses. The link between environmental voting records and cuts in emissions was statistically very robust, Dietz said.

The voting records of the states were recorded as a score between zero and 100, with some states getting almost full marks and others almost none. Vermont was the state with the greenest voting records and it had the second lowest emissions of all the states, with Rhode Island just behind.

Those states with the least green voting records were Texas, Wyoming, and Louisiana, and these states posted high carbon emissions. Even neighboring states can differ strongly, with North Dakota much less green and having higher emissions than South Dakota.

The next step of the research will examine whether environmentalism improves people’s wellbeing and happiness, as well as examining whether green activism has a measurable effect on other environmental indicators.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

The Latest

A Bug’s Life

I photograph insects because they are at risk, and visual recording of our natural world is a key conservation tool.

Amit Roy

Banks Lent $2.6tn Linked to Ecosystem and Wildlife Destruction in 2019

Lack of policies regulating impact on natural world means finance industry effectively bankrolling biodiversity loss, analysis finds

Patrick Greenfield and Phoebe Weston The Guardian

The Midas Touch?

A Canadian company wants to build a massive gold mine in Idaho’s Valley County. Under a pending agreement with the Trump administration, it could be let off the hook for the resulting waste.

Raquel Dominguez and Aaron Mintzes

Picking up the Pieces After a Disaster

Climate chaos is the through line in Rebuilding Paradise, but the documentary also offers tales of resilience and community.

Ed Rampell

Fossil fuel Phaseout, Fenceline Communities, Environmental Justice Take a Seat at the Table

Last night's presidential debate underscored the environmental movement's success in pushing the needle forward on the political discourse on climate change.

Maureen Nandini Mitra

‘We Don’t Have Any Choice’: The Young Climate Activists Naming and Shaming US Politicians

As the election nears, young Americans are calling on US politicians to take action on climate, police brutality and immigration

Nina Lakhani The Guardian