Bill McKibben, Naomi Klein Call for Civil Disobedience to Block Keystone XL Pipeline

If Approved, Keystone Would Increase US Oil Imports from Alberta Tar Sands

Bill McKibben, Naomi Klein, James Hansen, Maude Barlow, Wendell Berry and others have circulated a letter calling for civil disobedience to stop the Keystone Pipeline. The 1600 mile proposed pipeline would run from the tar sands in Alberta, Canada to oil refineries in Texas.

Photo by Shannon RamosKeystone pipeline under construction.

Thursday, the House Energy committee approved legislation that requires President Obama to make a decision on the Keystone Pipeline by November. The bill passed in a 33-13 vote with the support of six Democrats. It will move to the House for a vote later this summer.

The direct action to protest the Keystone Pipeline will take place in the second half of August.

Environmentalists opposing the tar oil sands exploration and the pipeline cite a number of reasons for serious concern. In an interview with Earth Island Journal, Bill McKibben said “The Alberta tar sands are one of the two or three biggest pools of carbon on earth. Building more pipelines means increasing the speed with which that carbon is poured into the atmosphere. As the NASA climatologist James Hansen said recently, if we start to use such unconventional oil, it’s ‘essentially game over’ for the climate.”

In addition to concerns about the greenhouse gas emissions generated and released into the atmosphere through oil sands production, environmentalists have also called attention to the Ogalalla aquifer over which the proposed pipeline would run and which it might potentially pollute.

In an interview with Earth Island Journal, Maude Barlow of the Council of Canadians said, “The Keystone Pipeline is a dangerous project. I object to it on several grounds. First, the proposed pipeline will travel right over the spine of the Ogallala Aquifer, 400 kilometers [248 miles] of a vast underground water source that supplies drinking water and irrigation to the whole region.” Environmentalists have pointed out that there are leaks at TransCanada’s existing pipelines.

Bitumen is another word for sticky tar-like form of petroleum that resides in Alberta’s tar sands and which the pipeline would transport. Barlow added, “Second, the processing of bitumen is environmentally damaging, both in the excessive greenhouse gases it releases, and in the water it pollutes. For every unit of oil refined, three to five units of water are destroyed.

“Finally,” Barlow states, “any investment in tar sands refining lengthens the life of the project and ensures that they will be mined for years to come when what we should be investing in is the alternative energy technology.

“The struggle has moved to the U.S. We want to send a message that the corporations can no longer make decisions for all the great issues of our time and that Canadians and Americans are standing shoulder to shoulder to oppose the growth of one of the most destructive projects on earth.”

McKibben stated that he hopes the call for direct action will bring out a diversity of people, “a great array of ages, including those of us who’ve been pouring carbon into the atmosphere for many years.”

The undersigned of the submitted letter include Maude Barlow (Chair, Council of Canadians); Wendell Berry (Author and Farmer); Tom Goldtooth (Director, Indigenous Environmental Network); Danny Glover (Actor); James Hansen (Climate Scientist); Wes Jackson (Agronomist, President of the Land Institute); Naomi Klein (Author and Journalist); Bill McKibben (Writer and Environmentalist); George Poitras (Mikisew Cree Indigenous First Nation); Gus Speth (Environmental Lawyer and Activist); and David Suzuki (Scientist, Environmentalist and Broadcaster).

Tina Gerhardt is an independent journalist who covers climate change, international negotiations and energy policy. Her work has appeared in Alternet, Environment News Service, Grist, In These Times, The Nation and The Progressive. She has also appeared on The Laura Flanders Show, the National Radio Project, KPFK and WBAI.

You Make Our Work Possible

You Make Our Work Possible

We are standing at a pivotal moment in history, one in which education and advocacy around the climate emergency, public health, racial injustice, and economic inequity is imperative. At Earth Island Journal, we have doubled down on our commitment to uplifting stories that often go unheard, to centering the voices of frontline communities, and to always speak truth to power. We are nonprofit publication. We don’t have a paywall because our mission is to inform, educate and inspire action. Which is why we rely on readers like you for support. If you believe in the work we do, please consider making a tax-deductible year-end donation to our Green Journalism Fund.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

The Latest

4 Major Environmental Treaties the US Never Ratified — But Should

Most of the world’s countries support these global agreements on conservation and pollution, but the United States is noticeably absent.

Tara Lohan

The Journey to Save a Turtle

Dan Thompson has dedicated 25 years to rescuing the Blanding’s turtle from the edge of extinction.

Jennifer Taylor

Turning Things Around on a Warming Planet

Netflix’s newest documentary featuring Britain’s most famous natural history filmmaker explores the causes of and solutions to the climate crisis.

Ed Rampell

A Woman Named Eunice Foote Documented Physics of Climate Change in 1800s

A rare female scientist in her time, Foote explicitly warned about the basic science. Why haven’t we listened more closely?

Sylvia G. Dee

Drought and Fire Are Pushing Australia’s Platypus to the Brink

Ecologists are racing to gather data on the curious monotremes as climate threat looms large.

John Pickrell

Salmon Nearly Boiled Alive in Pacific Northwest Heatwave Captured on Video

A conservation group recorded the video in the Columbia River on a day when water temperatures breached 70F.

Hallie Golden The Guardian