An Unfolding Disaster in Brazil

Unusually heavy January rains strain dozens of tailings dams in Minas Gerais state, raising risk of collapse.

Close to four hundred municipalities in the central Brazilian state of Minas Gerais declared a state of emergency after unusually heavy rains hit the region in early January. Widespread flooding submerged houses, blocked roads, and led to dozens of deaths and hundreds of thousands of evacuations. While extreme flooding is devastating under any circumstances, many communities in the region face another even more threatening situation: potentially unstable mine waste storage facilities that could collapse at any moment.

The 2015 collapse of a tailings dam in Minas Gerais’ Mariana district killed 19 people and left hundreds homeless. Current flooding in the region raises the risk of similar collapses. Photo by Felipe Werneck/Ibama.

While mining companies are quick to blame heavy rainfall for the problems with their tailings dams, dam instability is the result of years of decisions that prioritize profits over safety. Safer, more resilient tailings dams are more expensive to build and maintain. Mining companies have chosen cheaper options, like upstream dams, for tailings disposal. As climate change brings increasingly severe and extreme weather conditions, tailings dams designed and constructed to maximize profits will put more and more downstream communities at risk.

Brazil’s iron ore mines store their waste in earthen dams, called tailings dams, built from mine waste materials. Tailings dams, especially those constructed using upstream raises, are particularly prone to collapse if the tailings become saturated and the water level behind the dam rises. Before the rains started, the National Mining Agency (ANM in Portuguese) had already classified 36 dams in Minas Gerais (of the 40 nationwide) as being potentially at risk of failure. Three of those dams are at “imminent risk of collapse,” posing a terrifying threat to downstream communities.

Additionally with the recent rains, the Brazilian government specifically questioned the drainage systems and signs of erosion on 18 dams owned by Brazilian mining giant Vale as signs of potential failure. The Public Ministry’s office gave Vale 10 days to provide a report on what actions the company plans to take to ensure these dams do not collapse.

On Saturday January 8th, a waste pile collapsed at French steel pipe producer Vallourec’s Pau Branco iron ore mine. Mine waste flowed into a water retention dam on site, which caused the dam to overflow. Here are stunning videos of the event and the aftermath.

The waste pile was a co-disposal stack of waste rock and tailings, and was registered as a tailings dam with the ANM. The overflow flooded a major highway, sweeping away cars and leading to a two-day road closure. It also forced the evacuation of a staff member and 400 animals that the Wild Animal Rehabilitation Center located below the mine. According to the Observatório de Mineração, “the team responsible for the evacuation, around 60 people in 21 vehicles, faced the risks associated with going into an emergency area with the threat of [dam] break detected by the National Mining Agency.” Brazilian regulators fined the company $51.6M USD for the spill and suspended operations at the mine. This disaster did not come as a surprise to community organizations and local officials who had raised concerns about the stability of the waste disposal stack in 2021. Their warnings were ignored by the company and Brazilian regulators.

On January 11th, a dam at the Mar Azul mine, one of the three dams classified as at imminent risk of collapse, reportedly broke and sent tailings into downstream water bodies. Vale, the mining company that owns the three high-risk dams, released a statement saying the dam’s structural integrity had not been compromised and the runoff was caused by mudslides on the face of the structure. The downstream community has expressed fear that the entire dam will collapse. They have also been stranded by flooding. Recently, Vale built a 10 story retention wall to mitigate a potential tailings dam failure. The wall has caused rain waters to back up into the downstream community of Macacos. Fifty-eight families were evacuated and another 12 were stranded by floodwaters.

The community of Macacos isn’t alone in fearing a dam collapse. Dozens of communities across Minas Gerais are facing similar circumstances. The town of Congonhas is worried about the possible collapse of the CSN Casa de Pedra dam as water builds up behind the structure. An independent review of the dam identified possible stability issues in 2019 and with the recent flooding the ANM has raised its emergency classification to “not-controlled.”

The current disaster is unfolding in Brazil, but there have been at least seven tailings dam spills and failures in the last two months across the world. Governments must implement strong tailings regulations guided by public safety, like those outlined in Safety First: Guidelines for Responsible Mine Tailings Management.

The Movement of People Affected by Dams is asking for international solidarity to donate to humanitarian aid efforts for the thousands of people still living in emergency situations caused by the flooding and the unstable tailings dams. More information here.

Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

You Make Our Work Possible

You Make Our Work Possible

We don’t have a paywall because, as a nonprofit publication, our mission is to inform, educate and inspire action to protect our living world. Which is why we rely on readers like you for support. If you believe in the work we do, please consider making a tax-deductible year-end donation to our Green Journalism Fund.

Donate
Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

The Latest

The Shocking Truth About Sloths

As their forests disappear, sloths are climbing on dangerous power lines. Veterinarians and rescue centers are developing new techniques to help.

Madeline Bodin

Australian Gas Project Threatens Aboriginal Heritage

Activists worry a Scarborough gas field project could destroy petroglyphs while hurting climate goals.

Campbell Young

Bats of the Midnight Sun

Active in daylight during the Arctic summer and hibernating during the long winter nights, Alaska’s little brown bats are a unique population. Can their niche lives help them avoid white-nose syndrome?

Words Trina Moyles Images Michael Code

Land and Love in Melbourne

An Australian referendum to provide a political voice for First Peoples may have failed, but the push will continue.

Alda Balthrop-Lewis

A Canadian Corporation is Poisoning My Argentinian Community

We, the people of Jáchal, are fighting for the right to safe and clean water.

Saúl Zeballos

Climate Comedy Works. Here’s Why.

We all need some refreshing levity nowadays – especially during this politically heavy year.

Maxwell Boykoff Beth Osnes