A High Tide in Venice

The story of an iconic Venetian bookstore flooded during last year's historic high tide, and how rising sea levels threaten Italy’s City of Water.

On a cold November morning, Lino Frizzo opens the doors to his father’s Venice bookshop, Libreria Acqua Alta. He begins to reorganize books inside the 11-meter-long gondola, which sits in the middle of the store. The sun enters through the backdoor, which faces the canal, an alternative way to enter the shop directly from the water. The books are stored in gondolas and kayaks, canoes and bathtubs, a solution to protect them against the city’s rising tides. Tigre, one of five resident cats, sleeps lazily next to the till, occasionally peeking at the tourists entering the bookshop.

photo of acqua alta bookstore
Libreria Acqua Alta lost some 10,000 books during a high tide event that flooded 85 percent of Venice last November. Photo by Luca Zordan.

Luigi Frizzo, Lino’s father, founded Libreria Acqua Alta more than fifteen years ago. Its name translates as “high tide library,” a joke that turned out to be a bit too prescient when historic flooding hit Venice last November.

“It was a tragedy,” says Lino Frizzo. “The water entered the bookshop, knocked over the furniture, and filled the bathtubs full of volumes. All the books there were completely soaked.” After the flooding, he calculated between 100,000 and 120,000 euros worth of damage, and estimated that more than 10,000 books were destroyed. “We stopped counting at one point, it was too much,” he said.

Venice is a city built on water and high tides are a usual phenomenon. Tides in Venice depend on two things — astronomical factors connected to the movement of the moon and the sun, and meteorological factors influenced by atmospheric conditions, particularly the wind. High tide levels usually peak during the months of October through December — 70 percent of high tide events occur during this period — but on November 12 last year, Venice was hit by an unexpected and exceptionally high tide, second only to a 192 centimeter high tide recorded in November 1966.

“The tidal prediction threshold [that day] was 140 centimeters, so we lifted everything — books, postcards, photographs, print reproductions — to above 160 centimeters, just in case,” recalled Lino Frizzo. “But the tide was 47 centimeters higher than expected, it was a disaster,” he added, indicating with his hand how far the water had risen.

“I couldn’t save my books, the water rose too fast,” he said, “Our name is Acqua Alta, we are ready for water, but this time it was different.”

There are different thresholds that indicate tide levels, which consequently trigger an alarm system coordinated by the Centro Previsioni e Segnalazioni Maree, the service designed to monitor the tides in Venice, which alerts citizens via sirens, SMS messages, and social media in cases of high water.

“At an altitude of 110-plus centimeters, about 12 percent of the city is affected by flooding,” explains the Centro Previsioni e Segnalazioni Maree. “But when level reaches 140-plus centimeters, about 59 percent of the city is flooded.”

On the evening of November 12, the tide reached 187 centimeters. “You won’t believe it without seeing it, the water rises really quickly. In addition, the strong wind boosted the tide,” Lino Frizzo said. “The water entered the bookshop when nobody was here, it was ten in the evening. Otherwise the damage might have been less.”

photo of venice
Tigre, Libreria Acqua Alta’s oldest resident cat, sits next to the cash register keeping an eye on the tourists entering the bookshop. Photo by Lucrezia Lozza.

Over the centuries Venice has been built on 118 small islands in an area of inland sea water covering more than 50,000 square kilometers. This creates the Venetian lagoon. The city of Venice has tried to find solutions to stop rising seawater entering the lagoon and flooding the city. One of the solutions they came up with is MOSE, an engineering project aimed at safeguarding the city by installing gates on the bottom of the lagoon. The gates lift during a high tide event, creating a temporary barrier between the sea and Venice.

“We hope that sooner or later MOSE will be operational,” says Lino Frizzo. The project, which will cost an estimated 5.5 billion euros, was initially due for completion in 2016. It’s now expected to be completed in December 2021 at the earliest due to logistical issues, though a test was successfully completed during a high tide earlier this month.

However, there are concerns that even when MOSE does become fully operational, it will not be able to cope with quickly escalating challenges posed by climate change.

“MOSE won’t solve the problem because it has been designed without considering the significant sea level rise [expected] over the next decades,” climatologist Luca Mercalli said in an interview with the talk-show Che Tempo Che Fa a few days after the November 2019 flooding. “If MOSE is activated, it will be useful just for a few years.”

That’s because as sea levels rise — according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate the global mean sea level will rise between 0.43 meters and 0.84 meters by 2100 relative to 1986 to 2005 — the land Venice is built on is subsiding, causing the city to sink.

photo of venice
A view of the Canal Grande from Ponte dell’Accademia in Venice. The city was built over centuries on 118 small islands in an area of inland sea water, making it vulnerable to high tides and rising seas. Photo by Lucrezia Lozza.

As a result, research suggests that the flooding last November, the highest in 53 years, could be the new normal. “High tides are normal, but this high it is not,” says Lino Frizzo.

In the midst of tragedy, however, Libreria Acqua Alta staff were surprised by the overwhelming public response to their predicament.

“After the flooding, hundreds of people came here to help us to remove the soaked books,” says Lino Frizzo. A human chain took shape in the calle — a Venetian alleyway — and along the canal, where volunteers helped to pack the thousands of destroyed books into bags and onto boats.

In the months following the flooding, donated books began to arrive from all over Italy — from Rome, to Milan, to Veneto, and more.

Volunteers continued to help out even after the store was cleaned up. One of them, design student Maria Vittoria Miccoli, decided to do something to help Acqua Alta by transforming the ruined books into pieces of art.

“When I saw what happened to the books in Venice I thought to give them a second life,” says Vittoria. Acqua Alta gave Vittoria, and her colleagues Anna Carera and Ambre Carladous, 500 damaged books, and with the help of some volunteers on boats, she brought them to Milan. “We left the books out to dry for a night, but some of them were too damaged. We literally picked them out of the water, they were full of mold.”

She asked friends, colleagues, and lecturers to help her create artworks from the books. “Literally everyone participated, not just artists or designers,” says Vittoria. “Someone created a set of lamps, people illustrated the pages, someone else made paintings.”

Coltiva la cultura, by Sara Borsi, an IED University student, was created from the damaged books and auctioned to raise funds for organizations like the Querini Stampalia Foundation, which suffered extensive damage to its book collection during the high tide. Photo by Giovanni Lavarini.

Avrei voluto dirti…, by Francesco Leuce e Vittorio Albano, an IED University student. Some 100 people created artwork out of the books damaged in the flood. Photo by Giovanni Lavarini.

One hundred people between Milan and Bologna used their imaginations to create individual works of art for the project, which received support from IED University. The books merged into Maria Vittoria’s charity project Libri Controcorrente, with an auction of the books-turned-artworks aimed at raising money to preserve Venice’s book collections. The remaining artwork was displayed in an exhibition at Libreria Bocca, in Galleria Vittorio Emanuele.

“Our wallet was empty, but our hearts were full,” said Lino Frizzo. Without the volunteers, it would have been a complete disaster.”

Nearly a year passed since that exceptionally high tide, and Venice is entering the high tide season once again. A lot has happened since last November, not least of all the global Covid-19 pandemic, another setback for the bookstore, which relies in large part on tourist traffic. While last November visitors would have discovered books walking shoulder-to-shoulder in the small bookshop, eager tourists now wait outside for their turn to enter as Lino Frizzo limits store capacity.

Still, Libreria Acqua Alta’s doors are open. Lino Frizzo has reorganized the Italian literature in the ‘rescue boat’ in the back room. Cappuccino, the youngest of the book shop’s cats, sleeps in the gondola and gently swishes his tail over a photo album, whose cover portrays an old map of Venice’s canals.

You Make Our Work Possible

You Make Our Work Possible

We are standing at a pivotal moment in history, one in which education and advocacy around the climate emergency, public health, racial injustice, and economic inequity is imperative. At Earth Island Journal, we have doubled down on our commitment to uplifting stories that often go unheard, to centering the voices of frontline communities, and to always speak truth to power. We are nonprofit publication. We don’t have a paywall because our mission is to inform, educate and inspire action. Which is why we rely on readers like you for support. If you believe in the work we do, please consider making a tax-deductible year-end donation to our Green Journalism Fund.

Donate
Get the Journal in your inbox.
Sign up for our monthly newsletter.

The Latest

Why is Biden Considering this Man to Help Fight the Climate Crisis?

Ernest Moniz’s link to fossil fuels ‘is his entire professional career for the last couple decades, which is deeply concerning.’

Emily Holden The Guardian

The Lessons We Might Learn from Mosses

In a year of quarantine and remote learning, my children and I have found solace in the mossy world of our backyard forest.

Rachel Sturges

The Last Remaining Flocks of Gallos de León are Dwindling

For centuries, chicken breeders in a rural corner of Spain have produced feathers prized by fly fishermen. But economic hardships and environmental degradation threaten to end a way of life.

Bridget Ryder

Climate Activists Ramp Up Pressure on Biden with Protest Outside Democratic Headquarters

Groups to camp in Washington DC in protest of Biden’s hires of key staff with connections to the oil and gas industry.

Emily Holden The Guardian

Ferment. Foment: Food, Loss, and Belonging in a Foreign Land

Reclaiming one’s culinary heritage is a form of both coping and resistance. Collectively, such efforts are part of the larger struggles for social, economic, and environmental justice.

Rubeena Mahato

Are Wildlife Trade Bans Backfiring?

Trafficking in wild animal and plant products is driving species to extinction, but some researchers think restrictions only spur demand and make things worse.

Natasha Gilbert Knowable Magazine