Earth Island Institute logo, tap or click to visit the Institute home page

Go Back: Home > Earth Island Journal > Latest News > Post and Comments

Latest News

Awe and Wonder for Sale

Our public lands, now under siege, offer space for quiet reflection, contemplation, and renewed faith in our agency

After three days wandering off trail along the Continental Divide, we reached the beating heart of wild America. Before us: the headwaters of the Yellowstone River, an elk’s bugle from the point farthest from a paved road in the lower-48. Less than halfway into our weeklong, eighty-mile journey through northwest Wyoming, we’d already encountered more wildlife than we had seen in years of backcountry travel.

photo of yellowstone riverPhoto by Tim Lumley The Yellowstone River as it winds through Wyoming. Public lands are where many westerners live life to the fullest.

It was our layover day, time to climb to the sacred source of the Yellowstone and trade our fifty-plus pound packs for something a little lighter. I’d dreamed of this moment. The previous night’s thunderstorm — the type that makes you wonder if you’ll live to see another day — had left me sleepless and on edge.

Blue skies beckoned beyond our frost-covered tent. We struck out with high hopes across wide-open terrain. It wasn’t long before the tables turned. At a saddle before our final push, a brown giant peered down at us, only a hundred yards upslope. Our hearts pounded. Hump distinctly visible, the bear woofed, turned, and ambled out of sight. It was the fourth grizzly of the trip. We scanned for additional critters. Should we continue?

*          *          *

Many Americans would wonder what my wife and I were doing on that remote mountainside, dozens of miles from pavement, no one to call for help. But here in the West — and everywhere public lands are found — we feel the pull of empty spaces on the map. In the wild, our terror is our joy. Our isolation is our freedom. Refugees from modern civilization, we search for spiritual renewal, exercising our God-given quads in pursuit of our inalienable rights. For some, an experience like this might happen once-in-a-lifetime. For others, it’s a weekly ritual.

Our American birthright is 640-million acres of public land that belong to you and me. On April 15 — tax day — we make a mortgage payment on this land. Every time we fill a glass of water, cast a fly, or bask in alpine splendor, we reap the rewards of ownership.

As Westerners, public lands are where many of us live life to the fullest. Republican or Democrat, if we are lucky enough to enjoy these corners of wild America, our prized memories often harken back to experiences shared with people we love in places we can’t think of living without.

photo of Yellowstone headwatersphoto by Zack PorterA view from the author's weeklong journey though the headwaters of the Yellowstone River in Wyoming's Teton Wilderness.

At the age of 18, exhausted from battling years of depression, I found a friend in wild places and a new lease on life when I went to work for the Forest Service in Washington’s North Cascades. Public lands are where my wife and I were engaged, and where we brought our daughter within days of her birth. We’re a family of modest means and a 900-square foot house. But we’re downright wealthy every time we pull off on a dirt road and begin a new adventure.

It seems unconscionable, then, that elected officials would dare squander our heritage. In the first days of 2017, House Republicans made it easier to transfer federal lands, voting to prohibit calculation of lost revenue to taxpayers in land sales. In my home state of Montana, legislators led by State Senator Jennifer Fielder, CEO of the industry-funded, anti-public lands American Lands Council, are peddling resolutions to sell or transfer federal lands to the states. Opponents point out that state taxpayers would be saddled with astronomical management costs, which might force land selloffs to corporations and the wealthy and reduce public access. All of this despite the fact that a January 2017 Colorado College poll shows 56 percent of Westerners and 58 percent of Montanans oppose sale or transfer of federal public lands.

Our new Secretary of Interior, former Congressman Ryan Zinke (R-MT), claims to be a political descendent of President Theodore Roosevelt. But Zinke’s record shows that he has supported the sale or transfer of public lands in vote after vote, and done little to support conservation. It’s up to us to hold Zinke and other officials accountable, or risk losing what we love most about the West.

Thousands have rallied in state capitols across the West in recent months in defense of public lands. The resistance is working: after introducing a bill (HR621) to transfer three million-acres of public lands, Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-UT) withdrew it due to public outcry.

*          *          *

In this climate of greed, bullying, and compulsive scapegoating, we need places for quiet reflection and contemplation. Places where we are humbled by our insignificance, but also given renewed faith in our agency. Places where we are made to feel the stranger in a foreign land. Places that say: “Come as you are.”

Our Yellowstone River pilgrimage did not turn out as planned. Shortly after the day’s first ursine encounter, we spotted six more grizzlies blocking our path to the summit. Giddy with adrenaline, we watched the spectacle as long as fear allowed before turning around, awed by what we had witnessed, content to come up short of our goal.

It was just another day on America’s public lands.

Zack Porter
Zack Porter writes from Missoula, Montana.

Email this post to a friend.

Write to the editor about this post.

Subscribe Today
cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJFour issues of the award-winning
Earth Island Journal for only $10



This is a great piece.

Unfortunately, Zack Porter and the Montana Wilderness Association don’t always practice what they preach.

Right now, the Montana Wilderness Association is ‘collaborating’ with the timber industry to greatly increase industrial logging within National Forests across Montana.

The Montana Wilderness Association supports the release of Wilderness Study Areas for development, logging and motorized recreation, as we saw first-hand in their support of Senator Jon Tester’s mandated logging bill, the so-called Forest Jobs and Recreation Act.

On the Lolo National Forest the Montana Wilderness Association “collaborated” with the motorized recreation folks to open up recommended Wilderness Areas – and prime wildlife habitat – as snowmobile play areas. These recommend Wilderness areas were identified and established through the open, inclusive and transparent Lolo National Forest plan revision process.

Heck, just last month the Montana Wilderness Association announced that they had made a deal with mountain bikers to open up another recommended Wilderness area on the Lolo National (located in prime grizzly bear habitat) and establish a mountain bike play area.

As a longtime Montana Wilderness, public lands and wildlife advocate I can say in no uncertain terms that Montana Wilderness Association is not to be trusted when it comes to open, inclusive, transparent and science-based management of America’s public lands and our Wilderness legacy. Thanks.

By Matthew Koehler on Tue, March 28, 2017 at 12:00 pm

Beautiful narrative interwoven with the dangers and possible victories when it comes to our current administration’s policies. I will certainly be sharing your article with as many folks as I can!

By Erin on Sun, March 26, 2017 at 12:26 pm

Leave a comment

Comments Policy

Remember my personal information?

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

View Posts by Date View Posts by Author


Four issues for just
$15 a year.

cover thumbnail EIJ

Join Now!