Earth Island Institute logo, tap or click to visit the Institute home page

Go Back: Home > Earth Island Journal > Issues > Summer 2009 > Voices


The Kindest Cut

photo of a bald man standing with the Golden Gate Bridge in the backgroundLast year, I became castrated impotent sterile. That is, I had a vasectomy. While it’s actually a very common procedure (nearly 500,000 are performed every year in the US), it raises eyebrows – and a lot of questions.

The first one is always simply: Why?

Although this was a very personal decision for me, it was also a choice I made out of larger societal, political, and environmental motivations. I consider the environmental ones paramount. In an economic system that demands infinite growth with finite resources, not doubling my own consumption is one small stone in a big river.

More importantly, I live in the US, and any child I had would have been raised here and would consume (despite my best efforts) far more resources than I am comfortable accepting. Living even a modest lifestyle in the US comes as a direct result of the oppression, domination, and deaths of many unseen people, not to mention the exploitation of natural resources at rates that threaten the ability of our planet to sustain life. These facts shouldn’t be cause for guilt or shame; instead, they should spur us to organize to confront the systems and institutions that have created these problems. On a personal level, contributing another person to the system that I have spent my adult life fighting is just not something I’m willing to do.

The next question is usually: But what if you change your mind?

I view my decision as permanent. As I see it, I already made the decision years ago not to have children, based on sound, rational reasons. If I change my mind in the future, I believe that change would be fundamentally selfish, and I am comfortable committing myself to rational reasons now.

People typically follow up with: Aren’t there other forms of birth control?

Yes, of course, and most of us here in the US are lucky to be able to choose the form that is best for our lifestyles, our preferences, and our relationships. A vasectomy fit my needs best.

I guess there’s always abstinence, but that’s no fun, right? I suppose the rhythm method is an option, but almost everyone knows how (in)effective that is. Condoms are fine and dandy in many situations, but they have their downsides as well, and can seem pointless if you are in a monogamous relationship.

All the other common birth control methods have one aspect in common: They place the onus on women. Not only does our society expect women to deal with the logistics of birth control, but these methods also have severe physiological drawbacks, from roller-coaster hormonal changes to intensifying menstruation cycles to weight and skin changes. Although these methods have come a long way in a few decades, they still burden women and their bodies. Is it any coincidence that in a male-dominated society, the medical establishment has thus far focused on birth control methods that leave the burden solely on women?

For men, vasectomies are simple. There are almost no side effects and no long-term impacts; it’s a quick, low-cost, outpatient procedure. Having decided that I want to take an active role in birth control, a vasectomy is fair, easy, and it confronts my privilege on this issue.

What if you decide you want children in the future? people ask.

Many of my friends whom I deeply respect have chosen to have children or will do so in the future. Some people do feel that there is something special and important about having a blood-related child. I just don’t share that feeling.

There are thousands of beautiful children all over the world who need parents, and if I ever decide that being a father is something I want in my life, I would be remiss to ignore the existing children needing support and love. For me, adoption is the best option. We need more parents in this world, not more kids.

Finally, But don’t we need the smart, progressive people to reproduce?

I’m of the nurture-over-nature camp. I think the whole “passing on genes” obsession can sometimes border on eugenics. I’m fairly confident there is no gene that instructs your child to fight for justice, peace, and sustainability. That comes from living those values and instilling them in the communities we are a part of. That’s what I want to prioritize in my life – and I feel I can share those things more effectively without a child.

And besides – I’ve got messed-up teeth, I’m legally blind, bald, and have a history of heart disease. Let Matt Damon pass on his genes instead.

Matt Leonard lives in San Francisco, where he works on climate justice and energy issues, rock climbs, rides his bike, and eats yummy vegan food. He currently works with Greenpeace and Rising Tide North America.


Email this article to a friend.

Write to the editor about this article.

Subscribe Today
cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJ cover thumbnail EIJFour issues of the award-winning
Earth Island Journal for only $10



This article is a better articulated version of my entire belief system surrounding reproduction. It’s so refreshing to know that there are other people who can use reason over their biological urges! I congratulate you (and envy you, as a 26 year old unmarried female who hasn’t been able to find a doctor who will tie my tubes… I was lucky to get an IUD)!

By Bridget on Thu, December 03, 2009 at 1:24 pm

This ‘minor’ operation really was a life changing experience for me and of course my family who have also suffered as a result of it.
<a href=“”>Resveratrol</a> | <a href=“”>Teeth whitening</a>

By Adelaide on Thu, October 01, 2009 at 1:06 am

You are absolutely correct.The other expenses which can be included in a student’s cost of living in USA include expenses incurred on groceries, transport, utilities and recreation. A student in USA spends an approximate of $100 each on phone and groceries per month. An approximate cost of $150 each is incurred on transport and recreation.<a href=“”>Mrsa</a>

By janessa on Tue, September 29, 2009 at 10:57 pm

Imagine the flow of a river - pessimism lies in one direction, and optimism lies in the other.<a href=“”>computer engineering colleges</a> In order for pessimism to become optimism, you have to turn back the flow.edit; i use flow, because the nature of optimism and pessimism is that of a moving thing.Neither Optimism nor Pessimism can be considered to be permanent - at some point Pessimism will have been Optimism, and at some point Optimism will have been Pessimism.

By pamela on Tue, September 22, 2009 at 12:23 pm

Its really difficult to take this decision. hope you will not have any problem in future. wish you best luck for the same. Thanks for sharing.
<a href=“”>inbound call center</a>

By offshore call center on Wed, September 09, 2009 at 12:02 am

Well I think you are doing the right thing with choice! <a href=“—-One-of-the-Healthiest-Fruits-You-Can-Eat&id=2307928”>acai berry</a>

By Jeremy on Sun, August 30, 2009 at 5:17 pm

Most of us here in the US are lucky to be able to choose the form that is best for our lifestyles,our preferences,and our relationships.A vasectomy fit my needs best..<a href=“”>friend zone guide</a>

By friend zone guide on Thu, August 13, 2009 at 2:39 am

“We need more parents in this world, not more kids.” I really like this line. It’s really brave of you in addressing this topic Matt.
<b><a href=“”>Stillbirth</a></b>

By Stillbirth on Wed, August 12, 2009 at 9:18 am

Greatest work - I have position the script on my Christmas wish list and contributed it to my blog situation.
Thank you for alarming me to your position - I don’t read every post completely, I know, and this one slipped past my microwave radar.
<a href=“”>make more friends</a>

By zeeshan on Tue, August 11, 2009 at 10:19 am

I think that having the vasectomy is your choice and your preference and basing from your post I’d say you gave having the procedure a great a lot of thought. I just hope you don’t have any regrets regarding your decision.

@Mark: There i no such thing as NO RISK FOR COMPLICATION in any operation. I’m sure the surgeon explained and told you the possible complications for the procedure before you signed the informed consent form.

<a href=“”>erbs palsy</a>

By erbs palsy on Mon, August 10, 2009 at 7:22 am

had a vasectomy 2 years ago ‘on the NHS’ and have suffered continual pain and infections ever since. I now have chronic prostanitis with acute episodes which require long term use of antibiotics, probably for the rest of my life! I feel very bitter that these risks were not explained. This ‘minor’ operation really was a life changing experience for me and of course my family who have also suffered as a result of it.

By Mark J on Thu, July 16, 2009 at 3:42 am

Little link love for me wink

<a href=“”>forex news</a>

By Forex News on Tue, July 14, 2009 at 12:56 pm

I understand your point, and I respect your stance on the environmental impact, however, you cannot consider such a procedure to be natural, and therefore is a conflict of interest is it not?

By Forex News on Tue, July 14, 2009 at 12:55 pm

Leave a comment

Comments Policy

Please enter the word you see in the image below:


Four issues for just
$15 a year.

cover thumbnail EIJ

Join Now!